50 pages 1 hour read

Unmasked: My Life Solving America's Cold Cases

Nonfiction | Autobiography / Memoir | Adult | Published in 2022

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Key Figures

Paul Holes (The Author)

Content Warning: This section of the guide references violence, abuse, rape, and homicide.

The book’s narrator, author, and protagonist, Paul Holes possesses many traits that aid the work he does as a criminalist. He is fascinated by science and has a keen intelligence that allows him to understand complex scientific material, such as how DNA functions. Holes is also intellectually stimulated by the puzzle of solving a crime and goes about it in a way that proves effective: He is slow to jump to conclusions and instead carefully gathers all possible evidence, no matter how tedious the task may be. He often thinks unconventionally—a talent that leads him to focus on evidence that others might have overlooked. Further, his passion for his work and his empathy for the survivors of crimes allow Holes to work tirelessly, doggedly following leads until a case is solved. By contrast, Holes conveys that the managerial roles he took on at various points in his career were ill-suited to him—partly because of his lack of people skills and partly because they prevented him from examining cold cases. Over the course of the book, Holes often violates the mandates of his superiors by devoting time and energy to such cases.

As part of his analytical approach, Holes does not refrain from self-scrutiny, describing his social anxiety and struggles to emotionally connect with people. As an adult, Holes is able to understand that much of his anxiety around other people stems from a fear of rejection and of disappointing others. This suggests that Holes both values the opinions of others and sets high standards for himself that he expects others to hold him to. The nature of Holes’s work in some ways exacerbates Holes’s interpersonal difficulties, as his method of coping with the horrors he witnesses is to emotionally detach so that he can do his job accurately and diligently. However, this practice bleeds over into his personal life as Holes’s wife and children accuse him of being emotionally distant and unavailable, developing the theme of The Work-Life Balance Struggle. As his career ends, Holes receives professional counseling to confront and heal the psychological trauma he has endured.

Joseph DeAngelo

This key figure is unique in that his exact identity is not known to Holes until the closing of the book. DeAngelo is the perpetrator of the crimes Holes becomes most fixated on solving: a series of rapes in central California from 1977 to 1979 and a series of murders throughout Southern California in the early 1980s. Early in Holes’s investigation, DeAngelo is known as the East Area Rapist and the Original Night Stalker—monikers that underscore the seriousness of his crimes. These identifying labels are later replaced by the title The Golden State Killer, which reflects the geographic extent of his crimes, committed across a large swath of the state. Coined by a journalist, the nickname is also “catchy” in a way that helps garner media attention and public interest in solving the case.

In order to determine the perpetrator’s identity, Holes relies on identifying unique traits reported by multiple survivors. Certain actions—such as tormenting and taunting victims with phone calls and eating the food found in the house of the victims—recur from instance to instance. These details not only help to establish that all of the crimes were committed by the same person, but they also paint a psychological profile of the killer that is useful in identifying suspects. For example, Holes notes early in his investigation that some of the tactics the perpetrator uses to subdue his victims, such as shining a flashlight in their eyes, are ones used by police—a clue to DeAngelo’s identity as a former police officer. Holes also notices that the perpetrator seems not to be a “psychopath” because he shows discomfort regarding anything that personalizes his victims (such as informing him of a pregnancy). Indeed, in many instances, the perpetrator shows emotion after attacking his victims—crying or berating himself in a manner that suggests he understands the wrongness of his actions.

When the police finally apprehend DeAngelo, Holes notes several parallels between his demeanor and the reports of survivors. DeAngelo is able to sit, unmoving and unspeaking, for long periods of time—a technique he used to torment his victims and subsequently employs when refusing to speak to police. Even seemingly insignificant aspects of his personality—such as his insistence on a fastidiously manicured lawn—indicate DeAngelo’s need for control and dominance. Holes has spent decades constructing a profile of the Golden State Killer; with his identity discovered, he can put a face to the portrait and confirm that his ideas were correct.

John Conaty and Ray Giacomelli

Detectives Conaty and Giacomelli were partners in the Pittsburg Police Department who feature in Holes’s memoir. Holes meets them in 1998 when he is called to assist with a homicide. Conaty and Giacomelli are known nationwide among law enforcement as a skilled team and revered and respected for their success in solving homicide cases. Holes particularly emphasizes the strong bond between the two men; when Giacomelli is killed in duty, the pair is no longer the same. Before this, however, a rapport develops between the men and Holes that grows into a long-term friendship.

Holes describes Conaty as tall with a commanding presence and an impeccable and stylish fashion sense—traits that Holes suggest make him intimidating. Giacomelli, who also dresses impressively, is short with a bushy mustache. Holes notes that these physical differences make the partners a noticeable pair, their contrast like something from a detective film. Both are hardworking and dedicated police officers who are humble and down-to-earth regarding their accomplishments and roles. They joke and make fun of one another and others in their orbit; Holes understands that their penchant for teasing him is a sign that they have accepted and respect him. Indeed, their humor is a coping mechanism for dealing with brutal experiences. Holes stresses that both men are deeply empathetic toward their families and the victims they encounter in their professional lives; they are driven to solve cases with a ferocity that matches Holes’s own obsession. They are eager to learn about the scientific aspects of solving crimes, and Holes is honored to teach them.

Michelle McNamara

Michelle McNamara was a journalist and writer who wrote about true crime cases via a blog and came up with the Golden State Killer moniker. She is a minor but important figure in Unmasked whom Holes meets late in his search for the EARONS. Like Holes, McNamara is interested in uncovering the EARONS perpetrator to the point of obsession. She and Holes therefore begin a collaboration in which they trade theories and share reports and information.

This collaboration provides Holes with important evidence, but it also benefits him in less tangible ways. In McNamara, Holes finds a person who is just as driven to solve the case as he is. He emphasizes that McNamara’s intentions parallel his own: She is not seeking fame or money but truly empathizes with the victims of the crimes and their families. She is respectful of Holes and his professional boundaries and does not push him the way journalists are prone to. She works tirelessly and methodically in searching through evidence, both mentally stimulated by the puzzle, as Holes is, and compelled to complete the task she has set for herself. Holes describes McNamara as genuine and selfless, and she becomes a trustworthy and true friend. Upon her sudden and accidental death by overdose, Holes theorizes that the horrors of the case likely drove McNamara to self-medicate—a warning of what could happen to Holes himself.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 50 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 9,100+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools