62 pages • 2 hours read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of physical abuse, ableism, addiction, and cursing.
Lottie interrupts the principal’s speech about safety, demanding to know who hurt Hayley. The principal and teachers try to de-escalate, but Lottie asserts that Hayley can’t be blamed for starting fights when she doesn’t speak. Ollie adds that the school isn’t meeting Hayley’s needs, despite the funding they’ve received. They’ve failed to provide a personal aide or therapy, both of which are legally required. Ollie declares that Hayley will be attending Florrie’s private school from now on, and they storm out.
In the car, Ollie states that they’re a family. Hayley, in a big moment, speaks in front of him, repeating the word “family.” Later, Lottie expresses her fear to Ollie that if they lose him, it will break Hayley, just as losing their mother did. Ollie promises again to be their stable provider.
Hayley learns to swim at Ollie’s pool, with Florrie, Ollie, and Felix helping. Hayley is changing for the better at her new school, making friends, no longer being bullied, and even talking a bit. Lottie is grateful for these improvements.
When Blake and Claire arrive, Lottie notices Claire’s discomfort and Blake’s tight grip on her. Having witnessed abuse before, Lottie recognizes the signs.
Later, Lottie shares Hayley’s progress with Ollie, and he suggests making their engagement real. Lottie is taken aback, unsure if he’s proposing or if it’s too soon. Ollie reassures her that he will marry her and that nothing between them is temporary. Lottie voices her concerns about Blake, and though Ollie says that he’ll talk to him, he doesn’t fully believe her. His distrust leads her to withdraw.
At a business party, Vicky impresses the clients, but she’s distracted by Mike, who’s unusually dressed in a suit. Vicky has a secret crush on Mike but thinks that he’ll never see her as anything more than “defective.”
Lottie takes Vicky to the bathroom to compose herself, and Claire enters. They notice that she is hiding a bruise on her face with makeup. Lottie offers to talk, but Claire cuts her off and hurries out of the bathroom.
Outside, Blake pulls Lottie aside, furious that Ollie spoke to him about his issues. He grabs her roughly, but Lottie demands that he let go.
At the party, Blake accuses Lottie of ruining his family, blaming her for Ollie confronting him about his drinking. Lottie fires back, calling him out for his abuse against Claire and his threats.
Blake holds her back, preventing her from reaching Vicky before the fireworks. Lottie knows that the fireworks will trigger a meltdown. The tension escalates as Blake verbally abuses Lottie, gripping her so hard that bruises form. After he throws a punch, Lottie knees him in the crotch.
The fireworks trigger Vicky. Mike helps calm her down, taking her outside. Ollie then blames Lottie for not reaching Vicky in time, not letting her explain about Blake.
Blake drunkenly slurs that Lottie is a “psycho” who attacked him, but Ollie knows the truth from others at the party. When Claire approaches, Ollie sees her bruised face and realizes that Lottie was right about Blake. Ollie confronts Blake, promising that he will ruin him for hurting his family.
After putting Blake in his place, Ollie rushes outside to find Lottie, but she’s already gone.
After leaving Ollie, Lottie and Hayley return to their apartment. Lottie allows herself a brief moment of grief over Ollie and then moves on.
When Lottie picks up Hayley from her grandparents, Brenda and Tony state that they mentioned the idea of Hayley living with them so that she knows it’s a possibility before the hearing. This idea caused Hayley to fall silent with them. Lottie is frustrated by their actions.
Later, Ollie shows up, inspecting Lottie’s bruises from Blake. He begs her to take him back, apologizing and confessing his love. Ollie says that he knows she loves him too. Lottie refuses him, saying that his love is conditional and that she deserves more.
Over the next few weeks, Ollie stays true to his promise to Hayley, ensuring that she has a car to take her to private school and covering the expenses.
One day, he meets Lottie on her way from the train and asks why she returned the $50,000 to Margot. Lottie explains that the money was life-changing for her but that she didn’t want to feel obligated to his family anymore. Ollie tells her that he wants her to be his family, insisting that their engagement was never fake to him. His feelings were real. Lottie disagrees and walks up to her apartment.
When Hayley arrives in the town car, she shares her concerns about the upcoming hearing. She doesn’t want to live with her grandparents; she needs Lottie. Ollie promises her that no one will separate her and her big sister.
At the hearing, Lottie and Hayley feel overwhelmed. Suddenly, Ollie, Vicky, Margot, and the entire family show up to defend Hayley’s case. Ollie puts the ring back on Lottie’s finger, telling her to trust him. After Hayley leaves the room, they discuss the case. Brenda and Tony fight, but Lottie fights harder, stating everything she has done for Hayley and all she knows about her. Brenda and Tony don’t even believe in her selective mutism or therapy.
Ollie discusses his family’s power, wealth, and security. Hayley will never want for anything with them. The social services panel rules in Lottie’s favor, citing the resources and security of the royal family.
Hayley comes back into the room and shouts that she lives with her sister, which makes Lottie tear up. Hayley has never spoken out loud to so many people.
Brenda and Tony admit their mistakes. They all go out to eat as a family since Lottie doesn’t want to cut Hayley off from her grandparents.
Lottie and Ollie reconcile. She thanks him for all he did for Hayley and gives him another chance. She finally admits that she loves him too. They rekindle their romance.
It’s Christmas, months later. Lottie and Hayley have moved back into the mansion with Ollie. They’re all celebrating together, surrounded by warmth and love. Lottie and Ollie are happily married now, and Ollie has embraced his role as Lottie’s husband and Hayley’s second guardian.
Claire and Blake have divorced, with Blake working on his recovery. Vicky is thriving professionally, and Hayley’s bond with her grandparents has improved in healthier ways.
As a special Christmas gift, Hayley now gives Ollie adoption papers, making their family feel complete. Lottie, glowing with happiness, teases Ollie that he’ll soon be a father of two—because she’s two months pregnant. The entire extended family there is overjoyed, filled with love and hope for the future.
Florrie is a minor but vital supporting character who plays a crucial role in Hayley’s development, serving as a foil to her more timid and self-conscious nature. Outgoing, strong-willed, and confident, Florrie contrasts sharply with Hayley’s quiet, reserved personality: “Florrie was good at that—trying to make everyone feel better, looking after other people. She’d been doing it for the last month with Hayley at school […] [S]he’d marched in on Hayley’s first day and announced that Hayley was her friend and just a bit quiet” (253). This contrast highlights how Hayley’s growth is catalyzed by Florrie’s assertiveness. As Hayley befriends Florrie, she begins to trust and rely on someone who challenges her, offering both perspective and emotional support. Florrie’s confidence helps Hayley step outside her comfort zone, showing that she doesn’t have to be defined by her past trauma or judged for her quietness. Their friendship becomes a safe space for Hayley to practice communication and form healthy connections, moving her away from isolation.
Hayley’s gradual transformation reflects that growth is a slow, ongoing process and that friends can be relied on for support. Florrie’s strength provides the foundation for Hayley to rebuild herself and navigate the new school environment, a fresh start symbolizing emotional and physical safety. Because of Florrie’s influence as her opposite, Hayley’s relationships deepen, and the progress she makes with her friend allows for future development, especially her brave moment speaking at the hearing.
The stakes intensify as the abusive relationship between Blake and Claire becomes more evident. This conflict, foreshadowed by Lottie’s thoughts, exemplifies the novel’s underlying theme of sexism and injustice against women—an idea first introduced in the bar scene when Lottie was assaulted. Blake’s actions highlight his complete disregard for others’ well-being. Lottie and Vicky’s growing awareness that Claire is being abused adds urgency to the plot: “‘Oh, Claire,’ I said, my voice rough with emotion and concern. ‘Honey, what did he do?’ ‘Stop it,’ she hissed just as Vicky was coming out of the stall. […] ‘Claire?’ Vicky asked with a perplexed expression. ‘Why have you got a bruise on your cheek?’” (271). Blake’s role as the antagonist heightens as his behavior threatens not only Claire’s safety but also Lottie’s. At the party, his alcohol abuse, threatening words, and violent actions against Lottie reinforce the power imbalance, endangering everyone involved. Blake’s abusive actions trigger Vicky’s panic during the fireworks, Lottie and Ollie’s intense argument, and their eventual breakup. His use of physical power raises the stakes and underscores the gravity of abuse in relationships.
Lottie’s breakup speech exemplifies a climactic moment in the romance, adhering to romance tropes while reflecting The Redemptive Power of Love. Her dialogue establishes firm boundaries and asserts her right to unconditional love and respect: “You only love me if it serves your purposes—if I’m helping your family, if I keep my unpopular opinions to myself. Your love is conditional. I’ve had limits and conditions put on love my whole life and I’ve had enough of it” (296). This moment highlights Lottie’s evolution from being trapped in unhealthy patterns to standing up for herself. The breakup signals her shift toward self-empowerment as she refuses to accept less than she deserves. Following classic romance beats, the scene provides both emotional closure and the possibility of new beginnings. Lottie’s strong will and refusal to tolerate disrespect solidify her growth, defining her as an assertive, uncompromising individual. Once agreeable and fearful of losing her job, she now confronts Ollie directly and prioritizes herself. Despite loving him, returning the ring and rejecting his apologies are necessary steps that push her into the next phase of her life—and force Ollie to change in order to redeem himself. Lottie’s reclaimed agency makes her a symbol of growth and self-respect.
During the climactic hearing with social services, Lottie and Hayley showcase immense growth through their speeches, while Ollie and his family redeem themselves. Lottie’s heartfelt dialogue marks the culmination of her emotional journey and bottomless love for Hayley. She fully embraces her role as protector, challenging Brenda and Tony (antagonists who realize their mistakes) while asserting her commitment to her sister. Her transformation from being vulnerable to showing strength underscores themes of family loyalty and owning one’s power. Hayley’s public declaration to stay with Lottie is equally powerful, symbolizing her newfound courage: “‘I live with my sister,’ she said in a loud, clear voice which carried around the room. A tear did slip down my cheek then” (315). Once timid and fearful, Hayley now speaks up for herself, a dramatic transformation. Ollie and his influential family further elevate the climax by supporting Lottie’s case, using their power to ensure that Hayley remains with a guardian who will always do what is best for her, including providing her therapy. Their intervention highlights Lottie’s importance in Hayley’s healing and well-being and allows Lottie to forgive Ollie and truly trust him. Together, these moments reflect the strength of sisterhood and love.
Plus, gain access to 9,100+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features: